LIMITATIONS AND CONCERNS:

UV disinfection offers many advantages that are discussed in the advantages section. However, there are several limitations and concerns:

· UV disinfection provides no residual disinfection in the distribution system that protects’ against recontamination (USEPA, 2003). However, chlorine or chloramines can be provided for this and the EPA requires a chlorine or chloramine residual in the distribution system regardless of whether UV disinfection is used.

· Poor water quality can reduce the effectiveness of UV disinfection. Turbidity and dissolved or suspended matter may shield microorganisms from UV radiation or scatter UV light to prevent it from reaching the target microorganism (USEPA, 2003 ; Maggi et al., 2001). Some organic and inorganic compounds may absorb UV energy reducing transmittance (Maggi et al., 2001). When ferric chloride is used as a coagulant, the residual iron can absorb UV light, lowering the UV transmittance and increasing power costs (Maggi et al., 2001). Note, the LT2ESWTR and the draft Ultraviolet Disinfection Guidance Manual recommend a post-filter installation so that these should normally be lesser concerns.

· Inactivation applies a less than lethal UV dose that is designed to render Cryptosporidium non-reproducible. Damage to RNA/DNA by sub-lethal doses of UV light may be repaired through two major mechanisms: photoreactivation and dark repair. Photoreactivation occurs when cells are exposed to visible light after UV disinfection. The light activates enzymes that repair the thymine dimers. Dark repair enzymes excise the dimerized pyrimidine bases and reinsert undimerized bases (Ajy et al., 2001). However, this possibility is not believed to be a significant concern for properly designed and operated systems.

· Configuration of a water treatment plant or the available head may not allow for the installation of UV reactors between filters and the clear well (Bishop et al., 2003). This may necessitate UV installation after the high service pumps which is an undesirable location (USEPA, 2003).

· Lamp fouling is another concern. Lamp fouling is the buildup of chemical and biological films on the lamp sleeve surface, because it reduces the amount of UV energy reaching the water. Water hardness can create problems with keeping lamp sleeves clean (USEPA, 2003). According to Mackey et al. and Cushing as reported in the draft UV Disinfection Guidance Manual (2003), standard cleaning protocols and wiper frequencies (one sweep every 15 min.) are adequate for total calcium and hardness less than 140 mg/L and iron less than 0.1 mg/L at sites tested.

· Since lamps contain mercury, their breakage is a potential concern. If both the lamp and sleeve were broken, mercury would be released into the drinking water. Potential causes of on-line lamp breakage include debris breaking the lamp, overheated lamps, temperature differentials between the water and the lamp, pressures exceeding sleeve tolerances, electrical surges, improper handling and /or maintenance of lamp and sleeve, misaligned cleaning mechanism, and improper design and maintenance. While this is a concern, actual mercury releases are uncommon. If the potential causes of on-line lamp breakage are addressed in the design, operation, and maintenance of a UV disinfection facility, the potential for release of mercury should be minimal.

· UV disinfection does not provide inactivation of viruses at the dosage levels required for the inactivation of Cryptosporidium. Of the pathogens tested in drinking water, viruses are the most resistant to UV disinfection (USEPA, 2003). The UV doses for the inactivation of viruses are based on the dose-response of adenovirus because it appears to be the most UV resistant virus of those tested and is a widespread waterborne pathogen (USEPA, 2003). In general the UV dose required for 3-log inactivation of viruses ranges from 3 to 18 times that required for Cryptosporidium. If viruses are of concern in an individual water treatment system, the engineer and utility may need to consider another disinfectant.