BALLAST:
Lamp Ballast:
Lamp ballasts provide the energy needed to start and sustain gas discharges
in the UV lamp. The following photos show examples of a ballast and
a ballast cabinet.
Ballast
cabinets
Ballast
The design of the ballasts may have different forms based upon the
specific site needs and UV manufacturer design. According to information
supplied by different manufacturers, ballasts are expected to last for
10 to 15 years; however, the guaranteed life is from 1 to 3 years (USEPA,
2003).
Magnetic Ballast:
Magnetic ballasts may be capacitive or inductive. Capacitive ballasts
use capacitors to regulate the current flow (USEPA, 2003). One advantage
of the capacitive ballast is that it is not dependent on line voltage
for delivering power to the UV lamp. Also small changes in the power
quality are less likely to result in ballast failure. One disadvantage
of the capacitive ballast is the potential for faster aging of the electrodes
in the UV lamp due to more electrode sputtering.
Inductive ballasts use inductors in combination with the voltage and
lamp properties to control the current flow. An advantage of the inductive
ballast is that the UV lamp electrodes last longer because less electrode
sputtering occurs. Other benefits of the inductive ballast include a
more stable current output with greater resolution and control. Some
disadvantages of the inductive ballast are: they are less efficient
than capacitive ballasts, they cost more, they weigh more, and they
take up more space.
Magnetic ballasts are typically used in reactors using medium pressure
(MP) lamps.
Electronic Ballast:
Electronic ballasts are composed of several electronic components which
act together as a switching power supply. The electronic ballast can
send an electrical current up to 50,000 pulses per second to the lamp
compared to 100 to 120 pulses per second by the magnetic ballast (USEPA,
2003). The amount of current supplied to the lamp changes as conditions
change. For example, when the lamps are cold the ballast provides longer,
more frequent pulses of current to the lamp. The pulses become shorter
and less frequent as the lamps warm-up and reach normal operating conditions.
Electronic ballasts are a newer technology which means that there is
not a large amount of historic operational data to review. The electronic
ballasts used today are more reliable than the early models. Electronic
ballasts are more efficient and more compact in size and weight. They
also provide the ability for continuous power adjustment at different
settings. A disadvantage is that power fluctuations may cause a failure
but this can be offset by adding a buffer capacitor.
Operation of the ballasts generate heat. Too much heat can damage the
components and disrupt current flow to the lamp. To keep ballast temperatures
under the specified limit, low-pressure high-output (LPHO) and medium
pressure (MP) reactors use cooling systems. Cooling systems are generally
not necessary for low pressure (LP) reactors.
The selection of the ballast will be based upon site specific factors,
and the specific UV manufacturer applications. Each type of ballast,
the magnetic and electronic, have certain advantages and disadvantages.
A summary of the comparative advantages and disadvantages is presented
here.
Comparison of Magnetic and Electronic Ballasts
(USEPA, 2003)
|
Magnetic
Ballast |
Electronic
Ballast |
Comparative
Advantages
|
• Less potential for power interference due to stored energy
• More resistant to power surges
• More resistant to high temperatures
• Less prone to interference with electronic devices
• Less prone to sputtering (inductive less than capacitive)
• Proven technology (in use for nearly 70-years)
• Less expensive |
• More efficient
• Lighter weight
• Smaller size
• Less potential for heat generation
• Less potential for noise
• Continuous power adjustment
• Longer lamp operating life
|
Comparative
Disadvantages |
• Less efficient (capacitive more efficient than inductive)
• Heavier weight
• Larger size
• More potential for heat generation
• More potential for noise.
• Step-function power adjustment (number of steps proportional
to number of inductors/capacitors)
• Shorter lamp operating life
|
• More potential for power interference due to
stored energy (can be minimized by incorporating a capacitor)
• Less resistant to power surges
• Less resistant to high temperatures
• More prone to interference with electronic devices
• More potential for sputtering
• Newer technology (limited operating experience, especially
in larger
sizes)
• More expensive |
|